The Three-Question Postmortem

Three questions turn a wrong guess into a usable lesson.

Independent listening notes ยท 301 words

A wrong guess can stay a disappointment or become a lesson. The difference is three questions, asked in order, in writing.

First: what did I hear? This is a description, not a guess. Second: what did I assume? This is where the mistake usually lives, because assumptions are invisible until written. Third: what would have told me otherwise? This is the actionable part, and the answer is usually a specific audio feature.

The order matters. Asking what you heard first stops the analysis from being contaminated by the answer. Asking what you assumed second separates perception from inference, which are the two things the game is testing. Asking what would have helped third converts the round into a drill for next week.

I ask these questions for the three worst rounds of the week, not all of them. Three is enough to find a pattern, and more than three turns the review into a chore. The rest of the week's rounds get their one line and no postmortem.

The postmortem also has a diagnostic use. If the answer to the third question is always the same feature, that feature is your next study target. If the answer is always a decade, the problem is era sense. If it is always a lane, the problem is coverage.

Try it on the unlimited mode with three deliberately hard rounds and see what the third question produces. The answers are usually more specific than expected.

The postmortem is the engine of the review. browse the song list afterwards if you want to check whether the assumption was reasonable given the catalogue. It takes three minutes and it is the only part of the review that addresses a specific round. Most reviews stay general; the postmortem forces the specific, and the specific is what changes the next guess. Three questions are enough.